SAA-C03 SECURITY DOMAIN

AWS Security Group vs Network ACL (NACL): Stateful vs Stateless Explained Visually

Security Groups and Network ACLs both filter VPC traffic, but they operate at different layers with completely different state models. Watching a real return packet get blocked by a missing NACL ephemeral port rule makes the difference click permanently.

Practice SG & NACL Labs Free → Open Network ACL Cheatsheet

Security Groups = Stateful (ENI Level)

Return traffic is automatically allowed via connection tracking regardless of outbound rules. Supports Allow rules only.

Network ACLs = Stateless (Subnet Level)

Return traffic must be explicitly permitted (TCP ports 1024–65535). Supports both Allow and Deny rules evaluated in numerical order.

Explicit IP Blocking

Need to block a single malicious IP address inside a VPC? Use a NACL Deny rule with a lower rule number (e.g., Rule #50) before Allow All (#100).

Side-by-Side: AWS Security Group vs Network ACL (SAA-C03 Cheatsheet)

Step / DimensionComponentTechnical Behavior
ScopeInstance / ENI levelSubnet boundary level (applies to all instances in subnet)
StatefulnessStateful (return traffic auto-allowed)Stateless (must explicitly allow return ephemeral ports 1024-65535)
Rule TypesAllow rules only (implicit deny)Both Allow and Deny rules
Evaluation OrderAll rules evaluated together before decidingStrict ascending rule number order (lowest number wins first)

Terraform NACL Rule Allowing Return Ephemeral Traffic

resource "aws_network_acl_rule" "allow_ephemeral_egress" {
  network_acl_id = aws_network_acl.public.id
  rule_number    = 110
  egress         = true
  protocol       = "tcp"
  rule_action    = "allow"
  cidr_block     = "0.0.0.0/0"
  from_port      = 1024
  to_port        = 65535
}

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do AWS Network ACLs need ephemeral ports 1024-65535?

Because NACLs are stateless. When a browser connects to your web server on port 443, the browser uses a random high source port (1024-65535). The NACL outbound rule must explicitly allow those ephemeral ports for the HTTP response to leave the subnet.

Which AWS VPC firewall can block a specific attacker IP address?

A Network ACL (or AWS WAF at Layer 7). Security Groups only support Allow rules and cannot explicitly deny a single IP address.

Can I simulate Security Group vs NACL packet drops visually?

Yes — CloudTracer runs a stateful ConntrackTable for Security Groups and a stateless numerical rule evaluator for NACLs so you can see the exact rule that dropped a packet.

More Interactive AWS Architecture Guides